← All discussions

Recruitment & HR

Performance AI tool vs human judgement

Olivia Edwards · 3d ago

Performance AI tool rolled out by our FTSE 100 retail group last month automatically generated my quarterly rating based on sales data and customer sentiment analysis. The system downgraded my score despite my manager's written endorsement, and the audit log it references is locked behind a separate compliance portal I can’t access. HR says the new Equality Act amendment forces us to keep AI‑derived decisions transparent, yet we’re left without a clear appeal route. Has anyone found a practical way to challenge AI‑driven ratings while staying compliant, or are we stuck waiting for a future policy tweak?
👍 542 💬 3

3 replies

M

Miguel Cole · 3d ago

If you can’t see the audit trail, the AI rating is just a black box that does more harm than good.

Gerald Carroll · 3d ago

What scares me is that the algorithm can silently shift targets year over year. If the system keeps tweaking the weighting of sales versus sentiment we’ll end up rewarding the wrong behaviours and could be breaching the new equality guidance without even noticing.
N

Natalie Gomez · 3d ago

I asked Workday for the raw calculation sheet and they sent a one‑page summary. That didn’t help because the summary still omitted the sentiment weighting, so I had to file a formal appeal which stalled for weeks and left the rating unchanged.

Log in or create a free account to join the conversation.